Optimizing Insulation Design for Harsh Service Environments

Guidelines for insulator selection under pollution in AC are already available in IEC 60815 series 1, 2 & 3 and work is underway in IEC TC 36-WG 11 as well as in CIGRE WG C4-03-03 to extend them to DC. While these guidelines are intended to simplify application, they nevertheless offer sufficient information for preliminary design where pollution is not the main factor governing choice of insulation. A typical case would be designing insulators for EHV or UHV AC systems in areas with only moderate pollution where design and arcing distance is dominated by expected performance under switching overvoltage. Pollution performance requirements are then met by selecting insulators with a suitable creepage factor (CF).

The situation, however, is entirely different when pollution dominates design for AC, such as in desert or desert/coastal areas – and becomes even more critical under DC. Now, poor design can greatly impact total system cost. For example, overdesign (meaning expensive station insulators as well as over-dimensioned towers to handle unusually long strings) could result in unacceptably high investment costs. Similarly, under-design could lead to frequent and costly remedial maintenance.

This article from 2015, contributed by Alberto Pigini, past recipient of the Claude de Tourreil Memorial Award for Lifetime Achievement in the Field of Electrical Insulators, explained how selection of the proper insulators can best be accomplished whenever pollution is the dominant concern. His recommended approach is based on assessing site pollution severity as well as insulator strength characteristics. These are then combined to yield a statistical estimation of expected insulator performance.

It is worth noting that this process is especially important when it comes composite insulators. While less than optimal design could lead to flashover for ceramic insulators, it could result in complete failure of composite insulators. In fact, composite insulators offer the promise of superb pollution performance – but only if properly specified for their intended service environment.


Field Experience

The pollution design of insulation applied in desert environments has traditionally been based largely on IEC guidelines that recommended a USCD of 53.7 mm/kV for AC systems in heavily contaminated areas. It became increasingly evident over the years, however, that these guidelines were often not suitable for extreme desert and desert/coastal environments. This is demonstrated by several past case histories:

1. In Saudi Arabia, weather related power transmission line interruption rate per year in 1979 was 12/100 km circuit length. This was reduced to 0.53 for AC systems by 2001 but only due to insulator washing programs as well as specifying a minimum specific creepage distance (USCD) of 70 mm/kV, extended as high as 86 mm/kV for the most contaminated areas.

2. Transmission and distribution networks in Iran experienced numerous insulator flashovers over the years. Periodic cleaning of line and substation insulators was a common approach to reduce the problem but this solution had to be repeated at a rate that stayed ahead of the rate of contamination deposition. Records from the most heavily polluted regions of the country indicated that the frequency of insulator washing on lines was 5 or more times/yr and at a substations up to 20 times/yr.

3. Interruption of power supply due to pollution has almost ceased to exist in Jordan but this came about only after a program of systematic live line washing had been applied to the overhead transmission network.

4. Unsatisfactory line performance has been reported in places such as Algeria, Tunisia, Egypt, the United Arab Emirates, Israel, Morocco and Peru. This required costly maintenance including washing (either dead or live line) and application of silicone grease or RTV coatings.

[object object] Optimizing Insulation Design for Harsh Service Environments Screen Shot 2018 09 09 at 16
Salt and sand can accumulate at a rate of up to 2 mg/cm2 after each pollution event.
CLICK TO ENLARGE
[object object] Optimizing Insulation Design for Harsh Service Environments Screen Shot 2018 09 09 at 16
Accumulation of pollution on porcelain once installed at problematic coastal cable termination station.
CLICK TO ENLARGE

5. Harsh conditions also occur near a seacoast, even where there is no desert nearby. For example, it has been estimated that some 40 per cent of the power infrastructure in Mexico is located in polluted areas. The most common situation is salt fog that affects substations and lines located along the coast of the Gulf of Mexico. The critical season is from November to March during which there could be as many as 60 storms, called nortes, with resulting salt and sand accumulation on insulators of up to 2 mg/cm2 after each event. Depending on whether or not there was rain during the storm, live-line washing has had to be performed after every 3 storms (i.e. up to 20 times over only 5 months) to prevent the onset of flashovers.

Advertisement
[object object] Optimizing Insulation Design for Harsh Service Environments CSL Advertisement e1477326535980
[object object] Optimizing Insulation Design for Harsh Service Environments Screen Shot 2018 09 09 at 16
Deserts face growing resource development, contributing to more complex pollution challenges for power infrastructure.
CLICK TO ENLARGE
[object object] Optimizing Insulation Design for Harsh Service Environments Screen Shot 2018 09 09 at 16
A composite insulator solution could prove advantageous in harsh environments even i their service life proves much shorter than for ceramic equivalents.
CLICK TO ENLARGE

Overall, reported experience following application of composite insulators in these types of situations has proven mostly positive, although based on limited service time and relatively small populations of insulators.

[object object] Optimizing Insulation Design for Harsh Service Environments Screen Shot 2018 09 09 at 16
Silicone housed bushings in Israel were coated with RTV to alleviate concern about possible under-dimensioning due to increased pollution exposure.
CLICK TO ENLARGE

By contrast, experience with composite insulators in Peru has not been good with reports of many failures after only 4 years of service close to the coast where ESDD is 1.05 mg/cm2 and NSDD is 4.1 mg/cm2 (measured on a tower 3 km from the sea). The reason could be that the 60 mm/kV USCD typically selected, even if sufficient to prevent flashovers, was not enough to avoid premature ageing. This is confirmation that, when it comes to composite insulators, USCD must always be chosen with a view to both short-term and longterm performance.

Problems have also been reported in Israel and China, where flashovers occurred at substations, possibly due to under-dimensioning of the composite insulators employed. In the former case, the unconventional procedure of coating GIS silicone-housed bushings with RTV material was conducted as an added precaution.

Advertisement
BPG International Advertisement [object object] Optimizing Insulation Design for Harsh Service Environments BPG Banner

It is interesting to note that, from a total life cycle cost perspective, a composite solution could prove advantageous in harsh environments even if their service life proves much shorter than for ceramic insulators – assuming they eliminate the need for costly maintenance. Calculations from Saudi Arabia, for example, indicate that the life cycle cost of standard fog type insulators, which require washing every two months, is about 9 times that of silicone rubber equivalents.

[object object] Optimizing Insulation Design for Harsh Service Environments Screen Shot 2018 09 09 at 16
CLICK TO ENLARGE
[object object] Optimizing Insulation Design for Harsh Service Environments Screen Shot 2018 09 09 at 16
CLICK TO ENLARGE

Conversely, for the same life cycle cost as standard fog type insulators, silicone rubber insulators could economically be replaced with new ones every 2.8 years. Similar results have been found in Egypt. Seen from another perspective, the minimum service life required of a 220 kV composite insulator string is 75%, 50% or 37.5% of that for a ceramic insulator string under medium pollution (requiring 3-4 washes per year), heavy pollution (5-6 washes/year) and extremely heavy pollution (more than 6 washes/year) respectively.

All this experience highlights the importance of correct insulation design in desert and other harsh environments, based on:

• assessment of site severity conditions

• assessment of insulator performance characteristics

• application of a statistical approach

Assessment  of Pollution Severity

Assessment of Degree of Contamination

Although the general characteristics of all desert environments may seem similar (i.e. continuous pollution accumulation enhanced by periodic sand storms), actual contamination conditions can prove much different from one specific site to another. This is because the main effect of sand on an insulator depends on its chemical characteristics, especially its content of soluble salts.

[object object] Optimizing Insulation Design for Harsh Service Environments Screen Shot 2018 09 09 at 16
Targeted desert sites for gathering data on pollution accumulation on insulators (top Tunisia, middle border of South Africa & Namibia).
CLICK TO ENLARGE

Moreover, where desert and marine environments meet, research has demonstrated that marine pollution could extend inland by as much as 100 km in the case of high winds from the sea. Moreover, a marine environment can lead to very harsh conditions, with contamination levels far higher than 1 mg/cm2. In the case of storms, pollution accumulation can be so rapid that flashovers occur in just minutes.

Advertisement
[object object] Optimizing Insulation Design for Harsh Service Environments INTEGRATED Engineering Software Mar 11

By contrast, deposition of contaminants under normal maritime conditions usually results in gradual accumulation of pollution that combines synergistically with contamination from desert dust. The normal desert environment in many countries is now undergoing continuous change due to industrialization and resource development, which makes the problem of managing insulator contamination even more complex.

A general indication of the levels of contamination in desert environments is shown in Table 1 that summarizes data derived from the literature and related to selected countries where deserts make up a large proportion of the land mass. The data is not necessarily comparable since it was obtained using different reference insulators and measuring periods. However, it does illustrate that, even in the same country, contamination levels can vary significantly and reach localized levels with ESDD of 2 mg/cm2 and NSDD up to 10 mg/cm2 (with the ratio of NSDD to ESDD sometimes being more than 10).

Table 1: Pollution Measurements [object object] Optimizing Insulation Design for Harsh Service Environments Screen Shot 2016 11 25 at 15
Table 1: Typical Pollution Measurements Across Different Countries
CLICK TO ENLARGE
Extremely contaminated insulators in Iraq. [object object] Optimizing Insulation Design for Harsh Service Environments Screen Shot 2016 11 25 at 15
Extremely contaminated insulators in Iraq.
CLICK TO ENLARGE

Based on conducting these types of measurements, pollution maps can be developed that subdivide a country into different pollution zones, as shown in Fig. 1. Most such maps still consider only ESDD levels due to limited data available for NSDD.

Fig. 1: Example of pollution map used in Tunisia. [object object] Optimizing Insulation Design for Harsh Service Environments Screen Shot 2016 04 15 at 11
Fig 1: Pollution map developed for Tunisia.
CLICK TO ENLARGE
Fig. 2: Example of pollution build-up over time on different types of insulators. [object object] Optimizing Insulation Design for Harsh Service Environments Screen Shot 2016 04 15 at 11
Fig. 2: Example of pollution build-up over time on different types of insulators.
CLICK TO ENLARGE

In order to move toward optimized insulation design for pollution, the following points should be considered when developing new or refining existing pollution maps:

Advertisement
Yizumi Ad [object object] Optimizing Insulation Design for Harsh Service Environments INMR YIZUMI July edition

• Consider not only ESDD values but also NSDD since this latter parameter plays an important role in defining actual pollution severity;

• Implement mapping relying on a number of pollution measurement campaigns of sufficient duration and in representative locations so as to account for the random character of pollution phenomena. Data from certain countries suggest that recording periods of at least two years are needed to obtain sufficiently accurate indications of maximum pollution severity (see Fig. 2);

• Perform targeted measurements in areas of specific interest (e.g. where new lines or substations are to be built) or where complex interactions are expected due to mixtures of desert and industrial type contaminants;

• Finally, conduct measurements at experimental stations with insulators energized under DC voltages so as to obtain data that allow extrapolation of pollution mapping from AC to DC applications.

Assessment of Pollution Events

Contamination on an insulator must be made ‘active’ by efficient humidification (e.g. fog, drizzle, rain or condensation) in order to typically lead to pollution flashover. Evaluating the pollution events that trigger flashover is therefore also an essential part of the process of optimizing insulation design.

Although the general climate in desert environments may always seem similar, there could actually be great diversity in daily and seasonal weather patterns. During daytime, for example, it is typically very hot and humid in coastal zones. By contrast, inland areas are hot, dusty and dry. At night the dew point is frequently reached and fog also occurs at certain times of year. Finally, rain can occur after prolonged dry periods with potentially widespread problems on lines and at substations.

The incidence of ‘pollution events’ can vary greatly – even within the same country. For example, the number of days per year with heavy layer humidification at 10 different sites in Saudi Arabia was found to vary widely:

• Number of fog days: 0 to 64

• Number of rain days: 5 to 31

• Number of days with high humidity: 40 to 88

The number of such pollution events should be carefully evaluated for each service area where decisions on insulation design are to be made, adding together all days with fog, rain and high humidity. This is best done by analysing past meteorological data from the region.

Insulator Performance Under Harsh Conditions

Selection from among the different insulator alternatives (e.g. aerodynamic discs, anti-fog discs, aerodynamic longrods, coated insulators, composite insulators, etc.) should always be made taking into account specific application conditions. Therefore, whenever possible, laboratory tests should be performed on the insulators selected for the application while simulating expected contamination conditions, including non-standard contamination. For preliminary design work, available laboratory experience can be referenced, taking into account the specificity of the desert service environment in each case. This is summarized below, making reference to the salt fog and solid layer test methodologies.

The following formulas are proposed to obtain the reference unified specific creepage distance RUSCD for cap & pin insulators of standard profile for AC and DC voltages (see Figs. 3 and 4):

Advertisement
Desma Advertisement [object object] Optimizing Insulation Design for Harsh Service Environments DESMA INMR OnlineAd

For salt fog:

RUSCD = 16.5 *Sa0.22 (mm/kV, kg/m3) per AC

RUSCD = 15*Sa0.33 (mm/kV, kg/m3) for DC

with Sa being test fog salinity

For solid layer:

RUSCD = 50 *SDD0.22 (mm/kV, mg/cm2) per AC

RUSCD = 100*SDD0.33 (mm/kV, mg/cm2) for DC

with SDD being the standardized test pollution severity (obtained by contaminating the insulators with a slurry containing the necessary quantity of salt an d 40 g/liter of kaolin corresponding to NSDD of about 0.1 mg/cm2).

The USCD, unified specific creepage distance for other types of insulators may be obtained starting from the RUSCD applying the following coefficients:

For salt fog:

USCD = KCF*KD*KW1*16.5*SES0.22 *Kw2 (mm/kV, kg/m3) per AC

USCD = KCF*KD*KW1*15*SES0.33 *Kw2   (mm/kV, kg/m3) per DC

For solid layer:

USCD = KCF*KD*KW1*50*SDD0.22 *Kw2 (mm/kV, mg/cm2) per AC

USCD = KCF*KD*KW1*100 *SDD0.33 *Kw2 (mm/kV, mg/cm2) per DC

where:

KW1 e Kw2= influence of the degree of hydrophobicity of the insulator (in terms of wettability levels varying from 1 to 7.

KCF= correction to take into account the ‘creepage factor’ (ratio between total creepage distance and arcing distance)

KD= influence of diameter

Finally, being SDD the value to be applied in standard tests (corresponding to a non-soluble deposit density NSDD of 0.1 mg/cm2), the ESDD-NSDD value estimated in the field are to be converted to SDD. All the above is included in software developed for the accurate design of insulators from a statistical point of view.

Fig. 3: Salt fog. RUSCD reference USCD for standard cap & pin insulators. [object object] Optimizing Insulation Design for Harsh Service Environments Screen Shot 2016 04 15 at 11
Fig. 3: Salt fog. RUSCD reference USCD for standard cap & pin insulators.
CLICK TO ENLARGE
Fig. 4: Solid layer. RUSCD reference USCD for standard cap & pin insulators. [object object] Optimizing Insulation Design for Harsh Service Environments Screen Shot 2016 04 15 at 11
Fig. 4: Solid layer. RUSCD reference USCD for standard cap & pin insulators.
CLICK TO ENLARGE

Design for Harsh Environments

A general software program has been set up that can cover AC/DC ceramic and composite insulators with solid layer and salt fog type contamination. To illustrate the influence of different parameters, calculations are presented in the following example for anti-fog cap & pin insulators and composite insulators with a creepage distance to arcing distance ratio of 3.2 and with reference to AC application. Reference is made to solid layer and to the extreme case of ESDD=1 mg/cm2.

Advertisement
[object object] Optimizing Insulation Design for Harsh Service Environments OFIL banner 300X125 July1

The first case, which refers to a line equipped with ceramic cap & pin insulators with 10 pollution events/year and 100 contaminated insulators, shows the influence of NSDD. With reference to a target insulation performance of only one flashover every 10 years, the continuous line which corresponds to the laboratory condition (NSDD=0.1) indicates that a value of 53.7 mm/kV would be acceptable. But in the case of NSDD=1 (red curve), at least 67 mm/kV would be necessary. Where NSDD=10, 80 mm/kV would be necessary (violet curve).

Obviously, a much higher USCD is necessary if a larger number of pollution events are expected, e.g. in some desert areas where ESDD=1 mg/cm2 and NSDD=10 mg/cm2 and the number of pollution events vary from 1 (black curve) to 10 (red curve) and 100 (violet curve). In the last case, to realize a target of only 0.1 flashovers/year (i.e. 1 flashover every 10 years) 90 mm/kV would be necessary (see Fig. 6).

Fig. 5: AC cap & pin insulators. 10 pollution events, 100 insulators contaminated. ESDD=1 mg/cm2, NSDD = 0.1-1 and 10 mg/cm2. [object object] Optimizing Insulation Design for Harsh Service Environments Untitled 1 1 1
Fig.5: AC cap & pin insulators. 10 pollution events, 100 insulators contaminated. ESDD=1 mg/cm2, NSDD = 0.1-1 and 10 mg/cm2.
CLICK TO ENLARGE
Fig. 6: AC cap & pin insulators. 100 insulators contaminated. ESDD=1 mg/cm2, NSDD=10 mg/cm2, number of pollution events: 1-10 and 100. [object object] Optimizing Insulation Design for Harsh Service Environments 22222 1 1
Fig. 6: AC cap & pin insulators. 100 insulators contaminated. ESDD=1 mg/cm2, NSDD=10 mg/cm2, number of pollution events: 1-10 and 100.
CLICK TO ENLARGE

The influence of hydrophobicity of insulators is shown in Fig 7 which makes reference to insulators coated with RTV (10 pollution events, 100 insulators contaminated, ESDD=1 mg/cm2, NSDD=10 mg/cm2). A wettability of 7 (black curve), 6 (red curve) and 4 (violet curve) is assumed. It appears that, even if most of the initial hydrophobicity is lost, the flashover performance of the marginally hydrophobic insulator is still much better than for the uncoated insulator.

Fig. 7: AC cap & pin insulators. 100 insulators contaminated. ESDD=1 mg/cm2, NSDD=10 mg/cm2, 10 pollution events. Influence of hydrophobicity (black curve uncoated insulator with W=7), red curve coated but aged (W=6), violet curve coated with W=4. [object object] Optimizing Insulation Design for Harsh Service Environments 33333 1 1
Fig. 7: AC cap & pin insulators. 100 insulators contaminated. ESDD=1 mg/cm2, NSDD=10 mg/cm2, 10 pollution events. Influence of hydrophobicity (black curve uncoated insulator with W=7), red curve coated but aged (W=6), violet curve coated with W=4.
CLICK TO ENLARGE

However, it also has to be taken into account that polymeric materials are subject to premature ageing due to excessive leakage current and therefore actual ‘working USCD’ should be higher than found from the Figure. Similarly, the ‘working voltage’ should be sufficiently far from flashover voltage to assure low leakage current. This aspect can be dealt with in the program by requiring a much lower number of flashovers than for ceramic insulators. In the case examined here, for example, while 80 mm/kV would be necessary for W=7 (non-coated insulators) in order to assure a target of only one flashover every 10 years, a USCD of 60 can be selected for partially hydrophobic insulators (W=6), corresponding to very low probability of flashover (only one every 1000 years).

The software program can be used to evaluate the influence of many other parameters, such as creepage factor, number of insulators contaminated, diameter of insulators, etc. It should be pointed out that composite insulators would require even less creepage distance than in Fig. 7 due to their lower diameters (typical average diameter of 100 mm versus about 200 mm for cap & pin insulators).

Summary

1. Service experience confirms that IEC general indications are not adequate for desert as well as desert-coastal environments.

2. Pollution severity can reach extreme values in these types of areas but can also vary greatly from one site to another. Also, the number of pollution events can be highly variable. Consequently, accurate pollution mapping is necessary in order to realize optimized design of insulation.

3. Insulator type should be specifically selected considering the characteristics of the service environment and possibly tests should be carried out to assess performance of these insulators, simulating actual application conditions.

4. Preliminary design evaluation can be made by extrapolating available information on insulation performance.

5. To achieve final optimized design, a statistical approach must be used, as shown by the examples discussed above.